Handcrafted in Mukwonago, WI

Cookies worth driving across town for

Small-batch cookies baked from scratch by Rachel — thick, chewy, loaded with the good stuff. Plus hand-decorated sugar cookies that are almost too beautiful to eat.

Wisconsin delivery & pickup
Place an Order See custom cookies →
Nush Cookie Company signature Cookies and Cream
100%Made from scratch
every single batch
🍪 Fresh BakedMade to order,
never pre-made
Baked fresh to order
Premium, real ingredients
Wisconsin delivery + pickup
Custom gift boxes & corporate orders
The Artisan Side

Custom decorated sugar cookies

Each one hand-decorated with royal icing — painted, piped, and finished by Rachel. For birthdays, holidays, showers, corporate events, or any occasion worth celebrating properly.

Decorated Easter Bunny Sugar Cookies
Seasonal Collections

Spring bunnies, Valentine hearts, holiday designs — Rachel's seasonal sets sell out fast. Inquire early for holiday orders. No two batches are exactly alike.

Decorated Valentine Heart Sugar Cookie
Occasion & Gift Cookies

Birthdays, anniversaries, bridal showers, baby showers. Custom shapes, your colors, personalized designs — made to match your event perfectly.

Custom Decorated Sugar Cookie — Snow Angel
Fully Custom Designs

Have a specific vision? Rachel can bring it to life. From portraits to logos to detailed scenes — if you can dream it, she can ice it.

Sets start at $48 for 6 cookies  ·  Custom designs welcome  ·  1–2 week lead time recommended

Request a Custom Order
Rachel's cookies
Decorated cookie detail
Rachel's signature
gingham liner ✓
Our Story

Made from scratch, from the heart

Nush Cookie Company is Rachel Westphal's kitchen — a small, intentional operation in Mukwonago, Wisconsin, where every cookie is made by hand and every order gets her full attention.

No shortcuts. No pre-made dough. No factory. Just Rachel, her kitchen, and a genuine love of baking that shows in every bite. The drop cookies are thick and chewy. The decorated sugar cookies are little works of art. And everything is made to order, because that's the only way Rachel knows how to do it.

100%From scratch
SmallBatch always
ZeroShortcuts
The Nush Way

Every cookie, made with intention

01
🛒
Sourced with Care

Real butter, real vanilla, quality flour — ingredients chosen because they actually make a difference you can taste.

02
🧪
Mixed by Hand

Every batch made by hand in Rachel's kitchen. No industrial equipment — just feel, attention, and genuine care.

03
🔥
Baked to Order

Cookies are baked when you order — not sitting on a shelf. Crisp edge, chewy center, golden bottom. Every time.

04
🎀
Packed with Love

Packaged carefully and ready for delivery or pickup. Whether it's for yourself or a gift, every box goes out looking the part.

Corporate Gifting

Give gifts people actually remember

Onboarding boxes, client appreciation, holiday gifting — Nush Cookie Company's custom gift boxes make an impression that outlasts a branded pen by a long shot. We work with Wisconsin businesses of all sizes.

Custom branding on box and ribbon
Mix of drop cookies + decorated cookies available
Bulk pricing with volume discounts
Wisconsin delivery coordinated directly with you
Handwritten notes available on request
Inquire About Corporate Orders
🎁
Made for your team
Place an Order

Ready to taste the difference?

Fill this out and Rachel will be in touch within 24 hours to confirm your order, flavors, and delivery or pickup. Currently serving Wisconsin.